Risk Retention Groups, or RRGs, are a legitimate form of insurance. They're member-owned liability companies, authorized under federal law, and used across many industries to provide stable, tailored coverage at competitive rates.
The lower price isn't a mistake or an error in the quoting process. But it reflects real structural differences between an RRG and the admitted carriers most brokers place with. Those differences create specific RRG coverage gaps that matter more or less depending on where your company is and what your contracts require.
Key Takeaways
- RRGs are legally restricted to liability insurance only. Property Insurance, Workers' Compensation Insurance, and Crime Insurance can't be written through an RRG regardless of the carrier.
- Every RRG policy is required by federal law to disclose that state insurance guaranty funds don't apply. If your RRG fails, there's no state backstop for unpaid claims.
- RRGs write their own policy forms rather than using ISO standards. Endorsements that enterprise contracts routinely require (additional insured, primary and noncontributory, waiver of subrogation) may not be available or may not match expected language.
- Most RRGs are unrated by A.M. Best or carry ratings below the A- threshold that enterprise contracts and institutional investors typically require.
What an Risk Retention Groups Won't Cover
To evaluate an RRG quote accurately, it helps to understand what an RRG can and can't include by law, by structure, and by the policy forms it uses.
Coverage Lines Excluded by Law
The Liability Risk Retention Act (LRRA), codified at 15 U.S.C. § 3901 et seq., limits RRGs to liability insurance only. It's a statutory restriction that applies to every RRG regardless of how it's structured or priced.
Under that restriction, an RRG can’t provide:
Property Insurance (buildings, equipment, business personal property)
- Workers' Compensation Insurance and employers' liability
- Personal lines of any kind
- Health insurance
- First-party coverage of any type
In practice for technology companies, Crime Insurance is also off the table. RRGs don't write crime or fidelity coverage for tech companies, even though the LRRA doesn't name it specifically.
What this means operationally: if you buy Directors & Officers Insurance (D&O) or Errors & Omissions Insurance (E&O) through an RRG, you'll still need to source Property Insurance, Workers' Compensation Insurance, and Crime Insurance from admitted carriers separately. An RRG can cover your liability exposure. It can't cover your full risk program.
No State Guaranty Fund Protection
Here's a sentence that appears on every RRG insurance policy, required by federal law (15 U.S.C. § 3902(a)(1)(I)):
"State insurance insolvency guaranty funds are not available for your risk retention group."
State guaranty funds exist to protect policyholders when an insurance carrier becomes insolvent. When an admitted carrier fails, the state guaranty association steps in to cover outstanding claims up to state-specific limits. Coverage amounts and eligibility vary by state; the NAIC maintains a summary of state guaranty association programs.
RRGs are prohibited from participating in these funds under 15 U.S.C. § 3902(a)(2). If your RRG becomes insolvent, your pending claims may go unpaid or partially paid.
RRGs can be formed with as little as $500,000 in initial capital and surplus, with minimum requirements set by each domicile state. For long-tail lines like D&O and E&O, where claims arrive years after the policy period ends, the financial stability of your carrier matters more than it does for short-tail coverage. You're not just insuring this year's risk. You're insuring decisions you're making now that could surface as claims several years from now.
Policy Form and Endorsement Limitations
Admitted carriers use standardized policy forms developed by the Insurance Services Office (ISO). ISO forms carry decades of legal precedent. Courts have interpreted them across thousands of cases, claims professionals know how they work, and when an enterprise procurement team requests a certificate of insurance, the endorsement language they're looking for is written to ISO standards.
RRGs write their own policy forms, tailored to their specific member base. That base might be healthcare providers, trucking companies, or a professional niche. For a growth-stage technology company, that means reviewing policy language carefully to understand whether the coverage actually aligns with your contracts.
Endorsements that enterprise vendor agreements routinely require include:
- Additional Insured: Your client is named directly on your policy.
- Primary and Noncontributory: Your policy pays first, before any coverage your client has, and doesn't share the loss with theirs.
- Waiver of Subrogation: Your insurer waives the right to pursue your client for a covered loss.
- Contractual Liability Extensions: Coverage for liability you've assumed in a contract, like an indemnification clause in a master services agreement.
An RRG may not offer these endorsements in standard form. When it does, the language may differ from what a procurement team expects. Non-standard endorsement language can trigger back-and-forth with a client's legal team, or outright rejection.
There's also a coverage coordination issue. When D&O and E&O or D&O and Cyber Insurance are written on separate policies, gaps between them can surface at claims time. Admitted carriers using standardized forms have clearer coordination language built in. RRG forms, designed for different risk profiles, may not.
Financial Rating Gaps
A.M. Best evaluates insurance carriers on four dimensions:
- Balance sheet strength
- Operating performance
- Business profile
- Enterprise risk management
An A.M. Best A- rating or better is the standard floor in most enterprise contracts and institutional investor requirements.
Most RRGs are either unrated by A.M. Best or carry ratings below that threshold. New RRGs typically don't have the capitalization history needed to qualify. Some carry Demotech ratings, which serve specific regulatory purposes, but they're not equivalent to A.M. Best in enterprise or investor contexts.
An unrated carrier isn't automatically a poor choice. But it does mean there's no independent, public verification of that carrier's claims-paying ability. For a company approaching its first enterprise contract or a Series B close, that's worth factoring in.
Where These Gaps Tend to Surface Unexpectedly
The gaps above aren't abstract. They show up at specific moments, usually moments when you don't want to discover a coverage problem.
When an Enterprise Client Reviews Your COI
Enterprise and government contracts frequently include insurance requirements specifying that coverage needs to come from an "admitted" or "licensed" carrier. RRGs are chartered in one domicile state and registered (not licensed) in other states where they operate. Whether an RRG satisfies "admitted carrier" contract language depends on how that language is drafted and how it's interpreted.
Beyond the admitted carrier question, the endorsements described above are standard items in vendor agreements with large companies. If your RRG policy doesn't provide an additional insured endorsement in the form your client expects, your certificate of insurance may be rejected.
When that happens, the deal doesn't move forward. At best, you're resolving an insurance issue that should have been addressed before the contract was signed. At worst, you're re-binding coverage on short notice, often at higher cost. Either way, it's an operational problem as much as an insurance one: executive attention, legal time, and deal momentum all get pulled into something that should have been settled at bind.
When Investors Review Your D&O at a Raise
D&O coverage requirements from investors often appear in the limited partnership agreement (LPA) or a side letter. Series A and later investments typically include carrier quality expectations, not just coverage limits. An A.M. Best A-rated admitted carrier is the standard expectation in most VC D&O requirements, reflecting the fund's fiduciary obligations to its own limited partners.
An RRG-placed D&O policy may not satisfy those requirements. This surfaces during due diligence, not after the term sheet is signed. A GP's counsel reviewing your insurance before close will look at the carrier. An unrated RRG can trigger a request for replacement coverage at exactly the wrong time. Aligning your coverage with investor expectations before a round begins is considerably easier than correcting it in the middle of a close.
When an RRG Might Work for You
For companies with homogeneous, stable risk profiles, no enterprise contracts requiring admitted carrier compliance, and no investor D&O expectations, the gaps in RRG coverage may not be material. If your company is early-stage, bootstrapped or pre-seed, selling to customers who don't scrutinize your COI, and you have visibility into your RRG's financial health as a member-owner, an RRG can be a reasonable liability coverage choice.
The gaps become more material as your sales motion requires enterprise-grade insurance compliance, as you raise from institutional investors, or as you buy long-tail claims-made coverage from a carrier whose financial stability you'll depend on for years after the policy period ends.
The decision isn't whether RRGs are good or bad. It's whether the tradeoffs are acceptable for where your company is right now and where it's headed.
Coverage decisions that work at one stage don't always hold up at the next. An RRG policy that was fine pre-revenue can create real friction when your first enterprise client requests a COI, or when an investor asks about your D&O carrier during a Series B close. Understanding what's in the policy and what isn't is how you make the call with full information. If you want a review from advisors who know what enterprise contracts and investor requirements actually look like, talk to a Vouch advisor.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an RRG Provide Property Insurance for Your Business?
No. The Liability Risk Retention Act restricts RRGs to liability insurance only. Property Insurance, Workers' Compensation Insurance, and first-party coverage of any kind can't be written through an RRG. If you purchase D&O or E&O coverage through an RRG, you'll need to source Property Insurance and Workers' Compensation Insurance through separate admitted carriers.
What Happens If Your Risk Retention Group Becomes Insolvent?
State insurance guaranty funds don't cover RRG policyholders. Federal law (15 U.S.C. § 3902(a)(2)) explicitly prohibits RRGs from participating in state guaranty funds, and every RRG policy is legally required to include a disclosure stating this. If your RRG fails, pending claims may go unpaid or partially paid. Admitted carriers are backed by state guaranty funds up to state-specific limits.
Will Enterprise Clients Accept a COI From an RRG?
It depends on how the contract is written. If the vendor agreement requires coverage from an "admitted" or "licensed" carrier, an RRG policy may not satisfy that language. Beyond the admitted carrier question, endorsements like additional insured and primary and noncontributory coverage may not be available in the standard form enterprise procurement teams expect, which can also trigger rejection.
Do Investors Require D&O From an Admitted Carrier?
Often yes, particularly at Series A and beyond. Investors commonly include carrier quality expectations in LPAs or side letters, and the standard expectation is an A.M. Best A-rated admitted carrier. An unrated RRG-placed D&O policy may not meet those requirements, which can surface as a friction point during diligence at a round close.
What Endorsements Might Not Be Available From an RRG?
Availability varies by RRG and policy form, but because RRGs write their own forms rather than using ISO standards, common endorsements (additional insured, primary and noncontributory, waiver of subrogation, contractual liability extensions) may not be available or may not match the language large clients and their legal teams expect. It's worth reviewing the specific endorsements in your RRG policy before you sign a contract that requires them.
Is an RRG the Same as a Captive Insurance Company?
An RRG is a specific type of captive insurance company authorized under the federal Liability Risk Retention Act, owned by its policyholders and limited to writing liability insurance. Non-RRG captives can write a broader range of coverage lines but face different regulatory requirements, including being licensed in every state where they operate. RRGs can operate across state lines with a single domicile-state license.
Vouch Specialty Insurance Services, LLC (CA License #6004944) is a licensed insurance producer in states where it conducts business. A complete list of state licenses is available at vouch.us/legal/licenses. Insurance products are underwritten by various insurance carriers, not by Vouch. This material is for informational purposes only and does not create a binding contract or alter policy terms. Coverage availability, terms, and conditions vary by state and are subject to underwriting review and approval.
.png)
